The worst in the nation: National groups decry Montana’s ‘gender erasure’ bill
On Wednesday, representatives from the Human Rights Campaign, the nation’s largest LGBTQ rights organization, Georgetown University Law Center and the ACLU spoke about the bill, which they said may be the most radical bill in the country, even at a time when hundreds of bills dealing with the LGBTQ community are moving through legislatures throughout the U.S.
Doctors Warn Abortion Bill Would Restrict Montana Obstetric Care
“My major concern is how it will impact the ability to perform this procedure in an urgent fashion in a life-threatening situation,” [Tim Mitchell, a Missoula-based maternal-fetal medicine specialist] said, outlining situations where doctors are afraid to perform a D&E, even to save the life of a patient, for fear of legal retribution, a pattern that has taken shape in other states that have passed abortion bans.
Parental consultation abortion bill headed to House floor
“This bill concedes that parental consent is no longer needed in Montana, instead requiring consultation of a parent or guardian. That means that this Legislature is agreeing that parents have no say in consenting to their minors' abortions. Is that really the Legislature's intent?” asked Quinn Leighton, the director of external affairs for Planned Parenthood of Montana.
Montana lawmakers advance bills revising state abortion laws
HB 862 would block using state funding for abortion except in cases of rape, incest and when the woman’s life is in danger. It would bring Montana’s laws in line with the longstanding federal policy called the Hyde Amendment.
Montana has had a different standard. Since a 1995 court ruling, the state has used its own general funds to cover abortions that have been determined to be “medically necessary,” even if the mother’s life isn’t endangered.
Bill to provide 12 months of birth control passes Montana Senate
“And we all understand, while abstinence is the most effective form of birth control, it's kind of an unrealistic expectation a lot of the time. Plus, a lot of women have health issues that are controlled or helped out by taking birth control pills also. And those include things like ovarian cysts, endometriosis. They need the pills to help them function properly and correctly. And it's a matter of health. So this bill will basically help prevent delays in coverage,” Small said.
Montana's Senate Bill 458 will come with a moral cost
Financially, the cost of SB 458 could be billions. Morally, however, the cost to Montana will be immeasurable.
Montana bill aimed at strictly defining sex would exclude transgender people
If the bill becomes law, it’s unclear how its directives would be carried out, and legal experts say its provisions would be easily challenged in court. But the immediate effect would be to prevent transgender and gender-nonconforming people from being protected by anti-discrimination laws, increase hostility and scrutiny of individual gender expression, and potentially cost the state billions in federal funds.
Abortion restrictions spark conflict, hours of testimony in committee hearings
The bill’s language specifically bans “dismemberment abortion,” a broadly defined, nonmedical term that has been the basis for similar prohibitions on D&E procedures in other states.
A legal note drafted by legislative staff states that HB 721 appears to prohibit all such procedures at any stage of pregnancy and could trigger a constitutional conflict by infringing on the right to seek a pre-viability abortion.
State could lose “any, all or none” of $7.5 billion federal special revenue authority if ‘sex’ definition is enacted
A deep-dive fiscal note requested by legislative Democrats and distributed Friday says Montana could lose “any, all or none” of its $7.5 billion federal special revenue authority — federal grants, in other words — if Senate Bill 458, legislation to define “sex” in Montana law, is enacted.
Bill Aims to Prohibit Montana Medicaid Abortion Funding in Most Instances
“Forcing someone to give birth against their will is unconscionable, and Montanans will not stand for this government intrusion into our private lives and our personal decisions,” said Aileen Gleizer, with Missoula’s Blue Mountain Clinic. “If you pass this law, you’ll be responsible for harming low-income Montana families and burdening Montanans with costs of paying for forced child bearing.”
Gender-affirming care ban for transgender minors has second hearing
“Let’s face it, we are here today because some of you are uncomfortable looking at transgender people. So you are trying to make it harder for them to exist,” said Jessica Vangarderen Weingarten, a Belgrade mother with a transgender daughter.
Several bills in the Montana Legislature seek to restrict abortion access
The package of anti-abortion bills includes House Bill 625that would create a felony offense for providers who fail care for infants born after an abortion. The protection exists in federal law and infanticide is a crime.
Montana companies tell lawmakers restricting abortion would be bad for business
As Montana legislators consider a slate of bills to restrict access to abortion at the state level, some Montana companies with Fortune 500 clients are saying that would be bad for business here.
Legislative Deafness
This legislative session some legislators have stopped listening to their constituents and experts as they adopt new laws and regulations. These legislators are not hearing and are not willing to listen to reasonable arguments to amend or reject bad bills. The debate and passage in the House of HB 303, the Medical Ethics and Diversity Act, exemplifies this legislative deafness.
Legal Note finds House Speaker’s abortion bill may be unconstitutional
The legal notes concludes that given Montana’s broad right to privacy, HB 721 may raise a “constitutional conformity issue” because it infringes on a woman’s right to seek and obtain a pre-viability abortion and conflicts with precedent.
12-week abortion ban and other restrictions surge through House committee
Legislative staff attorneys also said the bill created “potential constitutional conformity issues” with the state Supreme Court’s 1999 ruling granting pre-viability abortion access from a chosen provider.
Montana lawmakers hear testimony on abortion legislation
Friday is the transmittal deadline, when any bill that doesn’t appropriate money or affect state revenues must pass through at least one chamber in order to keep moving forward. On Monday, the House Judiciary Committee held initial hearings on more than a dozen bills, including two that would tighten regulations on abortion in Montana.
GOP Bill Would Dictate Medical Emergencies for Medicaid Abortions
There were no proponents of the bill and 11 opponents. Opponents said the bill would not only infringe on Montanans’ right to privacy, but place people with time-sensitive medical emergencies related to their pregnancy in danger.
House committee holds hearing on Menstrual Equity Act
“This is a bill that really attempts to ease the burden of menstruation by protecting access to menstrual products in retail settings, schools, and homeless shelters and prisons. We have toilet paper that is freely available in bathrooms, so why are menstrual products any different?”